Senator Graham’s Inexplicable National ID Support


Posted by Jim Harper

The Cato Institute

Now is the time for thinking Americans to rid the Republican House of the RINO, Lindsey Graham. This guy has continuously been all over the map when it comes to voting on issues important to America? It’s time we send this representative packing. I think he and many democrats will have wonderful futures out in the desert as wind turbines. Random thoughts about a guy I once respected who turned gutless, J.C.

Compromise is catnip in Washington, D.C. That’s my best guess at why Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) would endorse New York Senator Chuck Schumer’s (D) widely reviled plan to create a mandatory biometric national ID system.

Schumer’s national ID plans have no more definition today than when he wrote about them in his 2007 campaign manifesto Postitively American. Among the thin gruel of that book is a two-page lump displaying more ignorance than understanding of how identity systems work and fail. Schumer doesn’t know the difference between an identifier—a characteristic used to distinguish or group people—and an identification card or system, which does the entire task of proving a person’s previously fixed identity. (My thin gruel on the topic is the book Identity Crisis: How Identification is Overused and Misunderstood.)

“All the national employment ID card will do is make forgery harder,” says Schumer.

No, that’s not all it would do: It would also subject every employment decision to the federal government’s approval. It would make surveillance of law-abiding citizens easier. It would allow the government to control access to health care. It would facilitate gun control. It would cost $100 billion dollars or more. It would draw bribery and corruption into the Social Security Administration. It would promote the development of sophisticated biometric identity fraud. How long should I go on?

Senator Graham’s take is equally simple: “We’ve all got Social Security cards,” he said to the Wall Street Journal. “They’re just easily tampered with. Make them tamper-proof. That’s all I’m saying.”

Lindsey Graham

No, Senator, that’s not all you’re saying. You’re saying that native-born American citizens should be herded into Social Security Administration offices by the millions so they can have their biometrics collected in federal government databases. You’re saying that you’d like a system where working, traveling, going to the doctor, and using a credit card all depend on whether you can show your national ID. You’re saying that bigger government is the solution, not smaller government.

The point for these senators, of course, is not the substance. It’s the thrill they experience as nominal ideological opponents finding that they can agree on something, securing a potential breakthrough on the difficult immigration issue.

They’re only ”nominal” ideological opponents, though. Chuck Schumer has always been a big government guy—and long a supporter of having a national ID, despite the lessons of history. Lindsey Graham is not really his ideological opponent. Typical of politicians with years in Washington D.C., Graham is steadily migrating toward the big-government ideology that unites federal politicians and bureaucrats against the people. Source:

About these ads

6 responses to “Senator Graham’s Inexplicable National ID Support

  1. Pingback: Obama’s Deadline Died; Time to Easter Mob the DEMS Townhalls « VotingFemale

  2. Pingback: breaking: Obama’s Panic Erupts; Cancels Mar 18th Trip; poor baby poor baby « VotingFemale

  3. Pingback: Pelosi paints Massa as the “Victim”; Swamp Woman Strikes Again « VotingFemale

  4. Pingback: Dana Carvey Does Obama, Enjoy! ;) (video) « VotingFemale

  5. Pingback: Obama Arrogance: Federalized Student Loans attached to Senate ObamaCare Reconcilation ramjob « VotingFemale

  6. Pingback: Pro-Lifers hand Pro-Abortionists their walking papers; Florida ‘Planned Parenthood’ Program admits defeat « VotingFemale

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s